Sunday, 27 September 2015

Is Syria becoming a new Afghanistan?


                      Syrian civil war began in 2011 had resulted in more than 4 million people fleeing to neighboring countries by far and over half of them are children as per the Unites Nations refugee agency. Besides, Amnesty International estimates that 220,000 people have been killed due to the clashes between Syrian Government led by President Bashar al-Assad and the rebel forces who are trying to topple his regime. Around 12.8 million people are in the urgent need of humanitarian assistance.

Background

                      Syria became an independent republic in the year 1946. However democratic rule was ended by a military rebellion in March 1949. In year 1954 Syria witnessed an uprising against the military power followed by two more uprisings in year 1963 and 1966. Finally in year 1970, General Hafez al-Assad, the Minister of Defense seized the power and became prime minister and in the following year 1971, he declared himself as President and he held that position until his death in 2000.

                    Bashar al-Assad took over as President after the death of his father Hafez, had initially promised and instigated hopes for democratic reforms in the country. Syria witnessed the birth of democratic forums and various political activists started debating political and social issues. However democratic climate ended with the arrest of ten leading activists propagating for democratic elections. Despite of the promising talks, Bashar al-Assad has failed to make Syria an Independent Republic.

Causes for uprising against Assad regime

                       Except for a minority of population like people with close contacts with the government officials and merchant class of Damascus (Capital city of Syria) Discontentment was prevailing very strongly against the Syrian government among the citizens of Syria particularly poor class. Social and Economic inequalities had increased dramatically in the Presidency of Hafez al-Assad and the situation was no different in the current regime of his successor Bashar al-Assad. Syria was also facing high unemployment rates.  Adding fuel to the fire, Syria experienced a most intense drought ever recorded in 2007 which lasted till 2010. Unlike the previous droughts, it had the devastating consequences on the Syrians and the Syrian economy. It led to widespread crop failure and increase in food prices and mass migration to urban areas. As per one estimate by top UN Official, drought has pushed 2-3 Million people in extreme Poverty. Growing discontentment for the Assad regime started taking wings and had a far reaching impact including the school children which the government decided to contain it by any means necessary. One such incident was arrest of 15 school children in 2011 for painting anti-government graffiti on the walls of school which led to huge outrage from the family members as well as the citizens. A protest started on 15 March 2011 demanding democratic reforms and release of the school children. However the peaceful protest had received an unwelcoming and a humiliating response from the authorities. As per the report by CNN, one official reportedly said to the family members pleading for the release of the children.

                      “Forget your children. If you really want your children, you should make more children. If you don't know how to make more children, we'll show you how to do it."

                       Eventually, the friction between the government authorities and protesters had grown and slowly the peaceful protest turned violent when police started attacking the protesters and killed four people on 18 March 2011. Violent protest have led to the emergence of numerous armed rebellion groups like “Ahrar al-Sham” implies Free Men of Syria(FSA) and Al-Nusra Front an affiliate of  “Al Qaeda” in Syria who have waged a war against the government forces and the escalation continued till 2014 until a self-proclaimed Islamic caliphate from neighboring country Iraq called ISIL – So called Islamic State of Iraq and Levant, an international terrorist group had started gaining grounds in Syria and by July 2014, ISIL controlled a third of Syrian territory. Ongoing war between rebel groups and Government forces has continued and the 4.5 years of civil war have resulted in the death of around 220,000 people, more than 4 million people from Syria fleeing to Europe for asylum and 50% of Syria’s Population is now displaced.

Dangerous Sea Journey towards Europe

                        More than 300,000 people have crossed to Europe by sea so far this year and more than 2,600 died doing so. Europe flooded by the migrants is facing the most dramatic refugee crisis since the end of World War 2. Countries with pro asylum policies like Germany and Sweden have promised to take the Syrian refugees and Germany alone have promised to absorb 800,000 refugees in this year. However Ex-Communist states like Hungary, the Czech Republic and Slovakia are against to accepting refugees and resisting the migrants from reaching their countries by constructing metal fences, deploying the military and Hungary Police have fired tear gas and water cannons on the migrants trying to cross the borders.  Germany is willing to accept the refugees. However the German chancellor Angela Merkel wants the refugee burden to be shared by the entire Europe as Germany alone can’t provide the asylum for all the migrants. 28 member nations of European bloc are divided on the acceptance of the refugees, so unwilling countries were given exemption to buy out their obligation on a temporary basis.

Besides, Europe many countries have promised to provide asylum for the refugees as listed below.

United States of America: As per the statement by US secretary of State John Kerry, United States will increase the number of refugees it takes in by 15,000 over each of the next two years, bringing the total by 100,000 by 2017.

Britain: Britain is to resettle 20,000 refugees over next 5 Years.

Australia: Australia is to accept 12,000 refugees from Syria after bowing to pressure from critics.

Lebanon: Lebanon hosts approximately 1.2 million refugees from Syria which amounts one in five people in the country.

Jordan: Jordan hosts 650,000 refugees from Syria, which accounts 10% of the population

Turkey: Turkey hosts 1.9 million refugees from Syria more than any other country worldwide.

Iraq: Iraq where 3 million people have been internally displaced in last 18 months hosts 249,463 Syrian refugees.

Egypt: Egypt hosts 132,375 refugees from Syria

Proxy war & Diplomacy

                       Instability in Syria may apparently look because of a civil war, however Syria have become a platform for Proxy war between United States and Russia. Besides powerful Middle East countries like Saudi Kingdom, Turkey, Israel and Iran had already took sides in this Civil war. United States and Saudi Kingdom wants to topple the Assad regime, So US is providing full ammunition support to the rebels including training to the rebels. Saudi, Israel and Turkey are working as allies with US. On the flip side, Assad enjoys the patronage of Iran and Russia. Iran and Russia are leaving no stone unturned to retain the Assad’s leadership which includes military and financial support. In recent times Russia has increased the military buildup in the Syria dramatically. Hence, turning the Syrian civil war into Proxy war between arch rivals i.e., US and Russia.

                        Until and unless USA and Russia reach to an agreement with respect to the Assad’s Leadership in Syria there is no solution for Syrian refugee crisis. If the world leaders doesn't figure out a diplomatic solution to this alarming crisis, Syria will turn into one more Afghanistan. After all, entire episode of Syrian war is no different from Afghanistan from a proxy war perspective. I hope we had learned enough from our history; else the quote by German Philosopher “Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel” will suit apt for our actions.

                    “The only thing we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history”